A pilot program to preserve and restore rural labor and delivery services

Open Access

Both California and the entire United States are struggling with a crisis involving the closure of rural labor and delivery units, threatened closures, and maternity deserts, primarily because the current reimbursement models do not provide sufficient financial support for sustainability.  

Rural labor and delivery services should be viewed as an essential public health resource rather than solely as a revenue-generating service line. Communities routinely support critical public safety infrastructure, such as police, fire, and emergency medical services, even when utilization is intermittent, because readiness itself has value. Access to emergency obstetrical care deserves similar recognition.

A promising solution has been proposed by Harold Miller, Director of the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, through the concept of standby capacity payments. Under this model, hospitals are compensated not only for services provided but also for the cost of maintaining the personnel, equipment, and readiness necessary to provide safe obstetrical care and emergency services on a 24-hour-per-day, seven-day-per-week basis. 

The reality is that not every rural labor and delivery unit can or should be saved. However, certain hospitals are particularly important because of their geographic isolation, established infrastructure, and demonstrated community need. These hospitals represent the best opportunities for preserving or restoring access to maternity care.

Mee Memorial Hospital in King City, California provided obstetrical services to the Southern Monterey Community since the facility opened in 1962.  However, in May 2020, amid the financial uncertainty created by the COVID-19 pandemic, Mee Memorial Hospital suspended operations at its labor and delivery unit.

Unfortunately, those services have never been restored. At the time of closure, approximately 320 babies were being delivered annually at Mee Memorial. Despite this significant volume, hospital administration estimated annual financial losses of approximately $5 million due to inadequate reimbursement and the high cost of maintaining a fully operational obstetrical service.

The closure of the unit significantly affected access to maternity care throughout Southern Monterey County. Women who previously delivered in King City must now travel approximately one hour north to Salinas for labor and delivery services.

Travel times can be substantially longer during fog, rain, or other adverse conditions. Some women have delivered along Highway 101 while attempting to reach Salinas, while others have delivered at home under unsupervised circumstances because of concerns about transportation or the ability to complete the journey safely.

The impact extends beyond routine deliveries. Pregnant patients presenting to Mee Memorial’s Emergency Department with obstetrical emergencies frequently require stabilization and ambulance transfer to facilities in Salinas. Prior to 2020, these patients could be rapidly evaluated and treated within the hospital’s existing labor and delivery unit and operating room. 

One former pediatrician colleague related being called to Mee Memorial at two in the morning, in the months before the labor and delivery unit closed, where a mother was suffering from separation of the placenta.  She and her baby were literally bleeding to death.  With quick action, the lady was taken to the operating room across the hall, and both the mother and baby survived. 

The pediatrician felt that both would have died if the mother would have had to be stabilized in the Mee emergency room and then transferred to a Salinas hospital for definitive care.

Therefore, I propose the creation of a Rural Maternity Restoration Pilot Program. Participation could be limited to hospitals that meet objective criteria, such as:

  • Labor and delivery services are currently closed or at imminent risk of closure.
  • The facility already possesses the physical infrastructure necessary for obstetrical care, minimizing capital construction costs.
  • The primary barrier to continued operation is financial rather than clinical or regulatory.
  • Historical delivery volume is/was at a certain, yet to be determined, number. Traditionally, at least 200 births annually were thought to be the threshold to ensure unit safety, however, the parameters could be widened to include hospitals with fewer deliveries.
  • The hospital is located at greater than a certain designated distance from the next hospital providing labor and delivery services.  This could be in accordance with the regulations that define Critical Access Hospitals, however, special consideration could also be given to hospitals under specified circumstances and demonstration of limited maternity access.  This would include hospitals serving a vulnerable or medically underserved population.

Participating hospitals would continue to receive reimbursement for all obstetrical and delivery services. In addition, they would receive standby capacity payments sufficient to cover the cost of maintaining a fully operational labor and delivery program, allowing the service to operate without financial loss. 

To encourage meaningful participation, funding should be guaranteed for a minimum of five years, with the opportunity for extension to ten years, if performance benchmarks are achieved. Hospital boards and administrators are understandably reluctant to invest substantial time and resources in restarting services unless there is a realistic expectation of long-term sustainability.

Mee Memorial Hospital is an ideal candidate for such a demonstration program. The hospital provided labor and delivery services continuously from its opening in 1962 until 2020. The primary reason for closure was financial. Prior to suspension, the unit delivered approximately 320 babies annually.

The nearest delivering hospital is roughly one hour away, and King City sits along a long stretch of the Highway 101 corridor, with hospitals approximately 50 miles to the north and south.  Mee Memorial’s website currently states: 

“While we do not currently offer labor and delivery or triage services, these are services we hope to bring back.”

That statement reflects a reality faced by many rural communities. The desire and need exist. The challenge is financial.

If California and the entire United States are serious about reducing maternal health disparities and preventing the expansion of maternity deserts, then rural labor and delivery units must have a financing model that recognizes the value of readiness and emergency capacity. Standby capacity payments offer a practical and targeted solution for achieving that goal. 

A precedent for a program with joint state and federal funding is the 95-210 Rural Health Clinic Act of 1977.  Facilities such as the Mee Memorial Clinics receive funding for their Medicaid (Medi-Cal) and Medicare patients on a cost-based reimbursement, which permits these facilities to stay open and to continue to provide care to patients.


Dr. Bruce D. Greenberg has been a practicing Family Physician at Mee Memorial Healthcare for more than 40 years. He can be reached via email at bgreenberg@meememorial.com, and would welcome your feedback.

Event Sponsors

Health Policy Commons

What are you trying to find out?

Browse by state